|
UAA Lecture at the Annual Meeting of the
19th Chinese Urological Association
Jae-Seung Paick, MD, PhD
Seoul National University College of
Medicine, Korea
It was my great pleasure and honor to have
been invited as UAA lecturer for the 2009
CUA meeting at Chengdu. The 16th Annual
Meeting of the Chinese Urological
Association was held on September 17, 2009
at Chengdu Century City International
Convention & Exhibition Center. Nearly 3000
urologists from China as well as many
international urologists attended the
meeting.
The opening ceremony was chaired by Prof.
Wei Qiang, Vice Executive Chairman of the
meeting. Prof. Li Hong, Executive Chairman
of the meeting delivered a welcome speech.
He thanked all the representatives for
taking part in the CUA2009 in Chengdu. Over
5000 submitted abstracts, nearly 2500
participants and many outstanding
international experts participated in this
meeting. Prof. Na Yanqun, CUA President
welcomed all the executives and colleagues
to Chengdu for the CUA2009. In his address,
Prof. Na remarked that China’s urology has
made dramatic improvements with efforts from
generations of urologists. As an efficient
organization, the CUA has made achievements
in various aspects this year. In future the
CUA will continue to work hard to realize
three missions, two goals and to build CME
system and promote internationalization for
the continuous development of China’s
urology.
Ms. Han Xiaoming, CMA Adjunct Secretary
General gave high praises on CUA’s
achievements. Mr. Chen Wenhua, Vice Governor
of Sichuan Province congratulated on the
CUA2009’s opening and welcomed all the
participants on behalf of the Sichuan
government. Prof. Chen Shan, CUA Secretary
General announced winners of 2009 Wu Jieping
Medical Science Award – Urology: Prof. Sun
Guang and Prof. Zhong Weide.
2009 CUA Honorable Membership Certificates
were awarded to Prof. Luc Valiquette, SIU
General Secretary, Prof. Christopher. R.
Chapple, EAU Adjunct Secretary General,
Prof. Anton J. Bueschen, AUA President,
Prof. Robert C. Flanigan, AUA Secretary,
Prof. Peter M.
Thompson, President of the Urology Section,
Royal Society of Medicine and Prof. Jae-Seung
Paick, KUA President. Prof. Sun said the CUA
Honorable Membership is to extend gratitude
to executives of international urological
organizations who have given great supports
to CUA and CUA’s internationalization and to
enhance communication and collaborations
with those organizations.
After the opening, the invited foreign
experts gave wonderful lectures, including
Prof. Anton J. Bueschen’s Evolution of
Urologic Imaging, Prof. Simon Tanguay’s
Management of the small renal mass, Prof.
Peter M. Thompson’s The evolution of
prostate biopsy and its safety, Anton J.
Bueschen’s How American Urology is Taught –
The role of the AUA, ABU and RRC and Prof.
Wang Run’s Radical Prostatectomy and Penile
Dysfunction: still a urological challenge.
The conference hall was crowded with
representatives who were eager to learn and
interact. Various topics ranging from female
urology, male infertility to laparosocopy,
robotics and single port surgery were
presented from various instiutions from
China and around the world.
The CUA2009 was a gigantic meeting of great
significance not only for CUA’
internationalization and development of
China’s urology but also the advancement of
urology to the intetrnational standard. Once
again, I thank UAA and CUA giving me the
wonderful opportunity to participate as UAA
lecturer on behalf of UAA.
Herein, I present my abstract for the UAA
lecture on “ A Journey to Continence: On the
Road to Better Surgery”.
INTRODUCTION
Stress urinary incontinence (SUI) is a
debilitating condition. To date, many
surgical procedures for the alleviation of
SUI have been developed, and most involve
the stabilization of the bladder neck and/or
the urethra. In 1996, a new surgical
technique, dubbed as the tension-free
vaginal tape (TVT) procedure, was developed
for the amelioration of SUI [1].
Subsequently, the attractiveness of such
minimally invasive techniques has led to
several modifications of the TVT procedure,
including the suburethral polypropylene
(SPARC) and the transobturator tape (TOT)
methods [2,3].
The underlying rationale shared by these
procedures is that the reaction of the
tissue to the tape results in the formation
of a controlled longitudinal deposition of
collagen along the length of the tape [1].
This then creates a collagen scar, which
stimulates the urethral support mechanism of
the pubourethral ligament. These procedures
have shown a great deal of potential and
have been associated with increased success
rates, while reducing operation times and
complication rates. These procedures can be
performed with the patient under only local
anesthesia, thereby, resulting in attenuated
hospital stay and postoperative recovery
periods. In this lecture, I will discuss the
current use of midurethral slings with a
focus on outcomes of these techniques in
specific clinical problems.
PREDICTOR FOR OUTCOME IN SUI: MAXIMUM
FLOW RATE
There are few data on factors predicting
the outcome after midurethral slings, and
the effect of patient characteristics
including urodynamic findings on the outcome
has not been systemically addressed. Thus
identifying factors that can be associated
with failure of midurethral slings would be
of utmost importance.
I evaluated the outcome of the TVT procedure
and examined factors predicting the outcome
of TVT [4]. A total of 60 women (aged 35–71
years) with at least follow-up of 2 years
were included in the study. At the latest
follow-up, 50 (83.3%) were cured of SUI. Two
patients had new-onset urge symptoms without
urge incontinence episodes. Multivariate
regression analysis showed maximal flow rate
(Qmax) to be associated with 0.9-fold risk
of the failure; no other parameters had
statistical significance. These findings
demonstrate that preoperative low Qmax may
be associated with the failure of the TVT
procedure.
WOMEN WITH INTRINSIC SPHINCTER DEFICINECY
Currently, the definition and diagnosis of
intrinsic sphincter deficiency (ISD) is
still unclear. However, maximum urethral
closure pressure (MUCP) of less than 20
cmH2O or Valsalva leak point pressure (VLPP)
of less than 60 cmH2O has been the
urodynamic criteria for the diagnosis of ISD.
The former examines the passive urethral
tone generated by urethral and paraurethral
tissues, and the latter determines active
urethral resistance during stress. However,
the effect of VLPP on the cure rate for the
TVT procedure has not been systemically
assessed in previous studies.
I evaluated the outcome at least 6 months
after the TVT procedure for SUI with low
VLPP and identified factors predicting the
outcome [5]. A total of 221 women 29 to 80
years old (mean age 55.2) were included.
Mean follow-up was 10.5 months (range 6 to
52). Patients were divided into 61 with low
(less than 60 cm H2O) and 160 with higher
(60 cm H2O or greater) VLPP. The overall
cure rate was significantly lower in
patients with low vs higher VLPP (82.0% vs
93.1%, p = 0.013). In women with low VLPP,
multivariate analysis indicated that urge
symptoms and low MUCP were independent
factors for treatment failure. These
findings suggest that women with urge
symptoms and low MUCP should be considered
to be at high risk for failure after the TVT
procedure when VLPP is less than 60 cm H2O.
WOMEN WITH LOW URETHRAL MOBILITY
Theoretically, the prognosis of the
mid-urethral slings is no longer determined
by sphincteric competence but rather on
urethral mobility, which allows it to bend
during exertion because the procedure is no
longer placed under the bladder neck but
under the middle of the urethra. Thus, one
would expect that proximal urethral mobility
is relatively more important than
sphincteric impairment for the success of
the mid-urethral sling procedures. However,
a recent study of TVT in vivo demonstrated
that the sling may have a tendency to rest
in the proximal third of the urethra, rather
than directly in the midurethra [6]. In
addition, with the TVT procedure, Q-tip
angle gradually approached baseline values
during the course of 1 year, with the most
significant difference from preoperative
values noted at less than 4 weeks of
follow-up [7].
The effect of proximal urethral mobility on
the cure rate for the mid-urethral sling
procedures was not systemically assessed in
previous studies. Recently, I demonstrated
that there was no significant difference of
the cure rate between the urethral
hypermobility group and the non-hypermobility
group in terms of the cure rate for SUI
although it was slightly lower in the non-hypermobility
group [8]. In this study, urethral mobility
decreased after the procedure in women with
urethral hypermobility but not in women
without urethral hypermobility. Klutke et al
[9] and Minaglia et al [10] reported that
the cure of SUI using the mid-urethral sling
procedure did not require the correction of
proximal urethral mobility. These findings
suggest that the lack of urethral mobility
should not be considered to be at high risk
of the failure after the midurethral sling
procedures in patients with SUI.
WOMEN WITH MIXED INCONTINENCE
While surgical correction of SUI is
associated with long-term success rate, urge
urinary incontinence (UUI) remains difficult
to treat as independent entities and as
co-factors in patients with SUI. The cure
rate of UUI in previous studies was somewhat
different. However, it must be remembered
that differences remain between the studies
in terms of study design and patient
characteristics such as age groups
evaluated, exclusion criteria, follow-up
duration and a small number of patients with
the presence of uninhibited detrusor
contraction during cystometry.
Recently, I evaluated the outcome at least 6
months after the TVT procedure in women with
mixed urinary incontinence (MUI) and
identified factors predicting persistent UUI
after the TVT procedure in these patients
[11]. A total of 274 women (SUI in 201 and
MUI in 73) with follow-up at least greater
than 6 months were included in the study.
There was no significant difference in the
cure rate for stress induced incontinence
between patients with SUI and MUI. However,
12 of 73 patients (16.4%) with MUI had
persistent UUI. Thus, the overall cure rate
was significantly higher in the SUI group
than in the MUI group (95.5% vs 78.1%, p =
0.001). On multivariate analysis, MUCP was
associated with a 0.9-fold risk of
persistent UUI after the procedure in
patients with MUI. These findings suggest
that low MUCP may be associated with
persistent UUI after the TVT procedure in
patients with MUI.
ELDERLY WOMEN
The prevalence of SUI increases with
advancing age. In elderly patients, SUI is
associated with worse health related quality
of life and health status since they have
more comorbidities. ISD increases in
prevalence with advancing age due to a
combination of factors, such as decreased
estrogenization, age related atrophy of
urethral tissue and increased likelihood of
a previous incontinence procedure. In
addition, ageing is responsible for
modifications at the vesical sphincteric
system level resulting clinically in a
bladder hyperactivity frequently associated
with SUI and a bladder hypocontractility
[12]. Thus, treatment of SUI in the elderly
population was complicated by the high
incidence of detrusor overactivity, voiding
dysfunction and ISD. In addition, their
surgical management poses a challenge since
elderly women are likely to suffer
significant pre- and intra-opeative
morbidity and have a slower recovery.
I evaluated clinical outcomes following
midurethral sling procedures in patients 65
years old or older and compared these
outcome measures to middle-aged women [13].
A total of 266 women who underwent
midurethral sling procedures with at least
follow-up greater than 6 months were
included in the study. Patients were divided
as the elderly group (65 years old or older,
n = 60) and the middle-aged group (45–64
years old, n = 206). Although postoperative
urge symptoms were more prevalent in the
elderly group (25.0%) than in the
middle-aged group (6.3%), there were no
significant differences between the two
groups for the rates of postoperative UUI (p
= 0.159). SUI was cured by 91.3% in the
middle-aged group and 85.0% in the elderly
group, respectively (p = 0.158). These
findings suggest that age does not seem to
be a significant risk factor for failure of
midurethral sling procedures.
OBESE WOMEN
The prevalence of incontinence has been
associated positively with body-mass index
(BMI). Among the different types of
incontinence, SUI is the type most closely
associated with BMI. Some authors have
reported a generally elevated
intra-abdominal pressure of obese patients
[14]. Obesity has been anecdotally
implicated in an increase in the technical
difficulty posed by traditional continence
surgery, and may therefore also be
associated with a higher degree of surgical
morbidity. Thus, obese women are frequently
denied treatment due to the surgical
difficulty and excess risk associated with
their treatment. Often, they are requested
to return after achieving a significant
weight loss, which many of them find
impossible to accomplish. Conventional
surgical procedures, e.g. Burch
colposuspensions, the
Marchall-Marchetti-Krants procedure, or
pubovaginal slings, are not only associated
with higher morbidity [14], but are also
quite a bit more difficult to perform on
this group of patients.
I evaluated whether or not the outcome of
mid-urethral sling procedures was influenced
by BMI in Korean women who suffered from SUI
[16]. A total of 285 women, ranging in age
from 28 to 80 years, all of whom were
followed up for at least 6 months, were
ultimately included in this study. The
patients were classified as follows: normal
weight, 18.5–23 kg/m2; overweight, 23–27.5
kg/m2; obesity, 27.5 kg/m2 or higher. I
noted bladder perforations in 11 cases
(4.9%, 3.8% and 2.2% in the normal weight,
overweight, and obesity groups,
respectively; p = 0.449). I determined there
to be no significant differences among the
three groups with regard to cure rate (p =
0.173). The rates of postoperative urinary
retention were 9.9% in the normal weight
group, 10.1% in the overweight group, and
15.6% in the obesity group (p = 0.396). I
determined there to be no significant
differences among the three groups with
regard to the persistence of urgency (p =
0.312). Seventy-nine patients (27.7%)
exhibited symptoms indicative of voiding
disorder (hesitancy, poor flow, or
sensations of incomplete emptying). The
postoperative development of these voiding
symptoms was not significantly different
among the three groups (p = 0.106). These
results demonstrate both the feasibility and
the safety of mid-urethral sling procedures
for obese Korean women who suffer from SUI.
A
WOMEN WITH RECURRENT SUI FOLLOWING
MID-URETHRAL SLINGS
Recurrent SUI after midurethral slings is
usually due to placing the tape too loosely,
so that it becomes slack with time, or the
mid urethral tape is misplaced. It can be
treated with secondary major
anti-incontinence surgery, such as
conventional colposuspension, the classic
sling procedure and repeat midurethral sling
surgery. However, little data is available
regarding an effective treatment for
patients suffering from recurrent SUI who
have already undergone midurethral sling
procedures. In addition, conventional
repeated anti-incontinence operations are
often difficult and may cause scarring and
fibrosis in the space of Retzius, distorting
the anatomical planes that increase the risk
of lower urinary tract injury.
To date, although little data is available
regarding an effective treatment for
patients suffering from recurrent SUI who
have already undergone mid-urethral sling
procedures, the shortening technique may
prove to be effective in the treatment of
failed TVT procedures. I reported the
results gathered in a trial of the
shortening techniques [17,18]. In these
patients, the tape was shortened by the use
of clips. Mean follow-up time after the
shortening operations was 9.9 months (range
6–18). The tape-shortening technique was
conducted with nine patients. Seven of these
patients recovered their continence, and no
one patient experienced any urinary
retention or other voiding difficulties. Two
patients reported only minimal stress
leakage and elected to undergo no further
interventions. These findings suggest that
tension plays a substantial role in
tension-free mid-urethral sling procedures.
CONCLUSION
Based on the long-term data on safety and
efficacy, the evidence so far appears to be
in favour of midurethral slings as the
minimal-access technique of choice for SUI.
Clearly, progress in the management of SUI
has occurred based on prospective and
randomized controlled trials, and the
growing interest for this field suggests
that this beneficial trend will continue.
Further well-designed trials with
standardized outcomes are required to draw
accurate conclusions.
REFERENCES
1. Ulmsten U, Henriksson L, Johnson P,
Varhos G. An ambulatory surgical procedure
under local anesthesia for treatment of
female urinary incontinence. Int Urogynecol
J 1996;7:81-6.
2. Deval B, Levardon M, Samain E, Rafii A,
Cortesse A, Amarenco G, et al. A French
multicenter clinical trial of SPARC for
stress urinary incontinence. Eur Urol
2003;44:254-8.
3. de Leval J. Novel surgical technique for
the treatment of female stress urinary
incontinence: transobturator vaginal tape
inside–out. Eur Urol 2003;44:724-30.
4. Paick JS, Kim SW, Ku JH, Oh SJ, Son H,
Park JY. Preoperative maximal flow rate may
be a predictive factor for the outcome of
tension-free vaginal tape procedure for
stress urinary incontinence. Int Urogynecol
J 2004;15:413-7.
5. Paick JS, Ku JH, Shin JW, Son H, Oh SJ,
Kim SW. Tension-free vaginal tape procedure
for urinary incontinence with low Valsalva
leak point pressure. J Urol 2004;172:1370-3.
6. Kaum HJ, Wolff F. TVT: on midurethral
tape positioning and its influence on
continence. Int Urogynecol J 2002;13:110-5.
7. Lukacz ES, Luber KM, Nager CW. The
effects of the tension-free vaginal tape on
proximal urethral position: a prospective,
longitudinal evaluation. Int Urogynecol J
2003;14:179-84.
8. Paick JS, Cho MC, Oh SJ, Kim SW, Ku JH.
Is proximal urethral mobility important for
transobturator tape procedure in management
of female patients with stress urinary
incontinence? Urology 2007;70:246-50.
9. Klutke JJ, Carlin BI, Klutke CG. The
tension-free vaginal tape procedure:
correction of stress incontinence with
minimal alteration in proximal urethral
mobility. Urology 2000;55:512-4.
10. Minaglia S, Ozel B, Hurtado E, Klutke
CG, Klutke JJ. Effect of transobturator tape
procedure on proximal urethral mobility.
Urology 2005;65:55-9.
11. Paick JS, Ku JH, Kim SW, Oh SJ, Son H,
Shin JW. Tension-free vaginal tape procedure
for the treatment of mixed urinary
incontinence: significance of maximal
urethral closure pressure. J Urol
2004;172:1001-5.
12. Resnick NM, Yalla SV. Detrusor
hyperactivity with impaired contractile
function. An unrecognized but common cause
of incontinence in the eldely patients. JAMA
1987;257:3076-81.
13. Ku JH, Oh JG, Shin JW, Kim SW, Paick JS
Age is not a limiting factor for midurethral
sling procedures in the elderluy with
urinary incontinence. Gynecol Obstet Invest
2006;61:194-9.
14. Noblett KL, Jensen JK, Ostergard DR. The
relationship of body mass index to
intra-abdominal pressure as measured by
multichannel cystometry. Int Urogynecol J
1997;8:323-6.
15. Cummings JM, Boullier JA, Parra RO.
Surgical correction of stress incontinence
in morbidly obese women. J Urol
1998;160:754-5.
16. Ku JH, Oh JK, Shin JW, Kim SW, Paick JS.
Outcome of mi-urethral sling procedures in
Korean women with stress urinary
incontinence according to body mass index.
Int J Urol 2006;13:379-84.
17. Paick JS, Ku JH, Shin JW, Park KJ, Kim
SW, Oh SJ. Shortening of tension-free
vaginal tape for the treatment of recurrent
incontinence. J Urol 2004;171:1634.
18. Paick JS, Oh JG, Shin JW, Kim SW, Ku JH.
Significance of tension in tension-free
mid-urethral sling procedures: a preliminary
study. Int Urogynecol J 2007;18:153-8.
|